February 7, 2024
Episode 197: The "Human Shields" Canard as Catch-All Colonial Absolution
Mind Map
Summary
Chapters
Transcript
- SSPEAKER_03
This is Citations Needed with Nima Shirazi and Adam Johnson.
- SSPEAKER_03
Welcome to Citations Needed, a podcast on the media, power, PR, and the history of bullshit.
- SSPEAKER_03
I am Nima Shirazi.
Shownotes
"Viet Cong Use Children as Human Shields," the Associated Press alleged in 1967. "'Civilian casualty?" That's a gray area," Alan Dershowitz argued in The Los Angeles Times in 2006. "We can’t ignore the truth that Hamas uses human shields,”"Jason Willick wrote in The Washington Post in 2023.
For more than five decades, military forces with overwhelming firepower, including the U.S., Israel, and others have accused enemy combatants of using “human shields.” According to these allegations, militant resistance throughout the world, from the Vietnamese National Liberation Front to Palestinian militants, herd civilians in front of them, or hide in hospitals, religious institutions, and other public places, in order to evade attacks. In turn, they force the enemy to “risk” killing civilians, and they themselves bear responsibility for those who are killed.
But rarely, if ever, have these accusations been true. Indeed, the term “human shields,” despite having a clear legal definition, has become a catch-all for militias or insurgency groups that merely operate among a civilian population, functioning as a convenient pretext for invading, occupying and colonial forces to kill civilians, and reinforcing racist conceptions about besieged populations. So why, and how, do media provide cover for governments that lie about and instrumentalize supposed “human shielding”?
On this episode, we dissect the decades-old “human shields” accusation, examining how it dehumanizes and militarizes people living under occupation and invasions, demonizes resistance movements, and sanitizes civilian-killing aggressors as reluctant actors who "simply had no choice."
Our guests are Neve Gordon and Nicola Perugini.
4 Talking Points Used to Smear DNC Gaza Protesters—And Why They’re Bogus
August 17, 2024 · 29min
Ep 207: US-Backed Killing of Journalists in Gaza and the Limits of "Freedom of the Press" Sloganeering
August 14, 2024 · 1hr 32min
News Brief: A Quantitative Analysis of US Media's Fentanyl Panic and How It Kills
August 7, 2024 · 29min
News Brief: Substance vs Vibes in VP Kamala Harris' Gaza PR Reboot
August 2, 2024 · 21min
Episode 206: How the Gambling Industry Swallowed Sports Media Whole
July 31, 2024 · 1hr 04min